That “Gorgeous Rehab” Is Actually an Alleged Money Pit According to a Recent Consumer Fraud Lawsuit

Alison Victoria, a Chicago native and one of the stars of HGTV’s “Windy City Rehab” has said that she wants to take over Chicago and put her stamp on every neighborhood. Whether fellow Chicagoans want that is another matter, and one that is currently being handled (at least in part) in the courts since Victoria and her partner, Donovan Eckhardt, is being sued by the buyers of one of their home renovations.

The house at 2308 W. Giddings Street sold for $1.36 million after Victoria and Eckhardt gave it a makeover. The end of the episode featuring the house showed it looking fixed up with fresh paint and chic furniture, but according to the current residents’ allegations (which are denied), the rehab was only skin deep, while severe structural damage continues to cause problems.

When James and Anna Morrissey bought their new home, they knew the roof needed to be replaced and Victoria and her team allegedly assured the Morrissey’s they would replace the roof after the sale at no cost to the Morrisseys. But the repairs were allegedly so slow in coming, and the damage to the roof was allegedly so extensive and caused so many alleged problems (including alleged leaking water into the walls and rooms of the house), that the Morrisseys allegedly had to hire their own contractor to replace it, which allegedly cost them $37,400. Victoria reimbursed them for $15,625, but a check from Greymark (Eckhardt’s company) bounced.

Victoria offered to cover his portion, but the Morrisseys claim they are fed up and ready to move out. In addition to the alleged problems with the roof, an upstairs shower has leaked water into a light fixture in the kitchen. As if that weren’t bad enough, nearly every window that was installed by Victoria and her team was allegedly improperly installed, allegedly allowing water to leak into the walls and rooms of the house. The Morrisseys further allege that water has pooled next to the house and into a neighbor’s property, and the door was allegedly improperly installed, leaving it crooked.

The lawsuit features a string of texts, emails, and photos between the Morrisseys and Victoria and Eckhardt, not only allegedly showing the damage, but showing that the defendants allegedly knew about the damage and allegedly failed to take action. The lawsuit alleges breach of contract, breach of warranty, defective and shoddy work, and consumer fraud.

The problems allegedly started the day after the Morrisseys closed on the property, and now they’re asking a court to reverse the sale of the house. They want their $1.36 million back, in addition to the $80,000 they have allegedly invested into repairs of the house themselves, plus an unspecified amount for punitive damages and emotional distress.

The Morrisseys aren’t the only ones who are allegedly unhappy with the rehab work Victoria and Eckhardt’s team have been doing in the area. Neighbors living near work sites have allegedly complained of noise, trash, and unsecured work sites. Victoria and Eckhardt’s team deny these claims as well as the claims in the lawsuit.

In July, Eckhardt and his company, Greymark Development Group, according to news reports, had their license suspended by the city of Chicago buildings department for having built three garages and garage decks without the necessary permits. They also allegedly endangered workers and neighbors by removing flooring and failing to put up the proper safety barriers. They deny these claims.

Last year, the city, according to news reports, issued several stop-work orders on various properties under rehab by Victoria and Eckhardt, including several properties that were featured on the show.

Super Lawyers named Chicago business dispute lawyers Peter Lubin a Super Lawyer and Patrick Austermuehle a Rising Star in the Categories of Class Action, Business Litigation, and Consumer Rights Litigation. Lubin Austermuehle’s Chicago auto fraud lawyers near Oak Brook and Naperville have over thirty years of experience in litigating auto fraud, franchise and dealer termination, breach of contract, complex class action, copyright, partnership, and shareholder oppression suits, non-compete agreement, trademark and libel suits, consumer rights and many different types of business and commercial litigation disputes.  Our Geneva and Wheaton car fraud and consumer protection attorneys near Chicago litigate CPO fraud cases and rebuilt wreck and flood vehicle cases against used car dealers and automobile manufacturers. We also assist Chicago, Evanston and Oak Brook area used car consumers who are victims of fraud and consumer fraud. You can contact on of our Auto-Fraud and consumer rights attorneys near Chicago and Oak Brook by calling (630) 333-0333 or our toll-free number (833) 306-4933.  You can also contact us online here.

Contact Information