What are the Best Defenses to a Class Action?

Based on our research and experience, the best defenses to a class action generally revolve around the requirements of typicality and adequacy of the class representative (Danis v. USN Communications, Inc., 189 F.R.D. 391 (1999)). The presence of even an arguable defense peculiar to the named plaintiff or a small subset of the plaintiff class may destroy the required typicality of the class as well as bring into question the adequacy of the named plaintiff’s representation. This fear arises from the possibility that the named plaintiff could become distracted by the presence of an individual defense, which could compromise the representation of the rest of the class (Al Haj v. Pfizer Inc., — F.R.D. —- (2020))(Lipton v. Chattem, Inc., 289 F.R.D. 456 (2013))(CE Design Ltd. v. King Architectural Metals, Inc., 637 F.3d 721 (2011)).

A defense unique to a proposed class representative does not need to be a sure bet to defeat the adequacy required for class certification; it only needs to be arguable and substantial (Al Haj v. Pfizer Inc., — F.R.D. —- (2020)). Similarly, defenses that are specific to the named representative may defeat the requirements of typicality or adequacy of the representative (Danis v. USN Communications, Inc., 189 F.R.D. 391 (1999)). However, these defenses need to be “unique, arguable and likely to usurp a significant portion of the litigant’s time and energy” (Danis v. USN Communications, Inc., 189 F.R.D. 391 (1999)).

It’s important to note that the assertion of individual defenses does not necessarily defeat a plaintiff’s ability to represent a class adequately (P.J.’s Concrete Pumping Service, Inc. v. Nextel West Corp., 345 Ill.App.3d 992 (2004))(Walczak v. Onyx Acceptance Corp., 365 Ill.App.3d 664 (2006)). A class action, in which a defendant is alleged to have acted wrongfully in the same basic manner as to the entire class, is not necessarily defeated merely because certain defenses may be urged against individual class members (735 ILCS 5/2-801).

Moreover, defenses that are unique to a named plaintiff are relevant to the inquiry into whether plaintiff’s claims are typical but are not necessarily dispositive of the issue (Sebo v. Rubenstein, 188 F.R.D. 310 (1999)). In many instances when a unique defense exists a class is defeated but the court is not required to deny certification for speculative reasons; the certification decision always remains within the sound discretion of the court (Danis v. USN Communications, Inc., 189 F.R.D. 391 (1999)).

Lastly, it’s worth noting that while the merits are not typically before the appellate court when reviewing the district court’s certification of the class, the claim of the class representative may be subject to a defense that makes it an inappropriate representative of the class because other class members may not be subject to the same defense, or perhaps to any defense (CE Design Ltd. v. King Architectural Metals, Inc., 637 F.3d 721 (2011)).

Take Action: Hire Lubin Austermuehle to Defend Your Class Action Lawsuit Today!

Facing a class action lawsuit can be daunting, but you don’t have to navigate it alone. Lubin Austermuehle is here to provide the expert legal defense you need. With our extensive experience, proven track record, and client-centered approach, we are uniquely positioned to protect your interests and achieve the best possible outcome.

Why Choose Lubin Austermuehle?

  • Extensive Experience: Our team concentrates in class action defense, bringing deep knowledge and strategic insight to your case.
  • Success: We have a history of winning dismissals, negotiating favorable settlements, and defending cases through trial.
  • Comprehensive Strategy: From challenging class certification to leveraging procedural defenses, we handle every aspect of your case.
  • Client-Focused: We prioritize clear communication and align our strategies with your business goals.
  • Resources: Our firm collaborates with top experts and uses advanced technology to strengthen your defense.
  • Cost-Effective: We provide flexible fee structures and manage litigation costs efficiently.

Don’t Wait – Secure Your Defense Now

The sooner you involve experienced legal counsel, the better your chances of a favorable outcome. Let Lubin Austermuehle be your trusted partner in this critical time. Contact us today to schedule a consultation and learn how we can help defend you in your class action lawsuit.

Contact Us For Free Comnsultation

Take control of your class action defense with Lubin Austermuehle. Reach out to us today and put our expertise to work for you. ontact us online or at 630-333-0333 for a free consultation.

Contact Information