You are sure your partner has been taking money from the company. You may even be right about how much. Then a friend who went through a business divorce tells you what his cost, and you start to wonder whether you can afford to be right.
Meanwhile, your partner has hired a large firm, and the company is paying the bills. Your share of the company’s money is funding the lawyers working against you.
Cost is the question most owners ask us second, right after “do I have a case.” In Illinois, each side usually pays its own lawyers, but a business divorce has more exceptions to that rule than most lawsuits. This post is for the owner weighing whether to sue, and it explains when fees can shift to the other side, when the company’s payment of the majority’s lawyers can be challenged, and how to think about cost against what is at stake.
Who normally pays the lawyers in an Illinois business dispute?
Each side, under the American rule, unless a statute or a contract says otherwise. Illinois follows that rule. The exceptions are where the planning starts, and in shareholder, LLC, and partnership disputes there are several.
Can a court make the other side pay my fees?
In some cases. Four routes come up most often.
The first is the Business Corporation Act. In a proceeding under section 12.56, the statute that protects shareholders in closely held corporations, a court may award reasonable fees and expenses against a party that acted arbitrarily, vexatiously, or otherwise not in good faith. 805 ILCS 5/12.60(j). In Machnicki v. Kurowski, 2018 IL App (1st) 171077, the First District affirmed an award of about $339,000 in fees and expenses under that section. The court rejected the argument that only conduct during the litigation counts; a court may consider bad-faith conduct connected to the dispute, such as an attempt to squeeze an owner out for less than his interest was worth.
The second is the contract. Many shareholder, operating, and partnership agreements include a prevailing-party fee clause. Read yours. A clause that lets the winner recover fees changes the risk on both sides, and it gives a minority owner with a strong case real leverage.
The third is punitive damages. Illinois courts have affirmed punitive damages against co-owners whose breaches of fiduciary duty were willful. In ICD Publications, Inc. v. Gittlitz, 2014 IL App (1st) 133277, the appellate court affirmed $2 million in punitive damages against a one-third owner who concealed and diverted company money for years. In Kazemi v. Maron Electric Co., 2026 IL App (1st) 250908-U, a Rule 23 order, the Appellate Court affirmed punitive damages against a majority owner and CEO who set out to rig the company’s valuation and wipe out a minority shareholder’s contractual buyout. Punitive damages are not fee awards, and they are never automatic, but in the right case they can far exceed the cost of the litigation.
The fourth is the derivative recovery. When an owner sues on behalf of the company and recovers money for it, Illinois courts can award the owner’s reasonable fees out of that recovery or against the wrongdoer, because the suing owner’s work benefited everyone who owns the company. In Lasday v. Weiner, 273 Ill. App. 3d 461 (1995), a two-shareholder case, the appellate court held that an interim fee award to the minority shareholder who sued derivatively was not premature, and it approved charging the fees to the majority shareholder personally because he had taken company money and refused to return it. Our post on derivative lawsuits covers when a claim belongs to the company.
Can the company pay my partner’s lawyers?
Sometimes. Check whether the law and the company’s documents actually allow it. The Business Corporation Act allows a corporation to indemnify officers and directors for defense costs in some circumstances, and to advance those costs before the case ends, generally on the officer’s or director’s undertaking to repay the money if it turns out he was not entitled to indemnification. 805 ILCS 5/8.75. Indemnification has limits: the statute ties it to conduct in good faith and in a manner the person reasonably believed was in, or not opposed to, the corporation’s best interests. LLC operating agreements usually have their own indemnification provisions.
In our experience, majority owners often treat the company as their litigation budget without asking whether the bylaws, the operating agreement, or the statute actually permit it. A minority owner can challenge payments that the governing documents do not authorize, demand the required undertaking, and ask the court to account for every dollar if the majority loses. When the company is paying the majority’s lawyers to defend claims that the majority looted the company, that fact also tends to interest the judge.
What does a business divorce actually cost?
It depends on how far it goes. A dispute that resolves after a demand letter, a records request, and a few months of negotiation costs a fraction of one that goes through discovery, expert valuation, and trial. The single largest variable is often the valuation fight, because both sides may need business appraisers and forensic accountants.
Three facts tend to bring the cost down. The first is a clear record: owners who arrive with organized documents and a written timeline save their lawyers time. The second is an early buyout window. In a corporation, filing a section 12.56 petition opens a 90-day period in which the company or the other shareholders may elect to buy the petitioner’s shares at fair value, 805 ILCS 5/12.56(f), and many cases resolve then. The third is a realistic goal. An owner who knows whether he wants to stay, sell, or dissolve can aim the case at that result instead of fighting on every front.
Fee arrangements in these cases vary with the claims, the stakes, and the evidence. We discuss the options in the first meeting.
What does it cost to do nothing?
This is the number owners leave out. A minority owner who stays quiet while distributions stop, salaries climb, and related-party payments drain the company is watching the value of his interest shrink every quarter. Meanwhile, deadlines run. The Fourth District held in Thompson v. Whalen, 2023 IL App (4th) 220668, that the five-year limitations period applies to section 12.56 claims. Contract deadlines in buy-sell provisions can be much shorter.
The math usually comes down to a comparison. On one side is the realistic cost of the case. On the other is the fair value of the interest, as the statute defines it, minus what the majority is offering. If your interest is worth $1.2 million at fair value and the offer is $400,000, the case is about $800,000. That number, not the hourly rate, is the place to start. We explain fair value in our post on why the fair value of your shares is higher than the offer.
Frequently asked questions
If I win, will I get my fees back?
Not automatically. You may, if a contract provides for fees, if the court finds the other side acted arbitrarily, vexatiously, or in bad faith under section 12.60(j), or if the recovery comes in a derivative case. Punitive damages can offset cost in cases of willful misconduct.
Could I be ordered to pay their fees?
Yes. Section 12.60(j) can run in either direction, and a prevailing-party clause cuts both ways. Machnicki involved an award against the owners who tried to squeeze out their co-owner. A claim brought in good faith on a solid record is the best protection.
Can the company pay for my lawyer?
Rarely, if you are the one suing the company or its controllers. If you are an officer or director defending claims, check the bylaws, the operating agreement, and 805 ILCS 5/8.75.
How do I keep costs down?
Organize your documents, write your timeline, know your goal, and move early, while the evidence is fresh and the statutory windows are open.
If you want a clear read on what your case is worth and what it will take, call DiTommaso Lubin, P.C. at 630-333-0333 for a free consultation, or contact us online.
Big-firm firepower, with the partners on your case
Peter S. Lubin and James V. DiTommaso are Chicago business litigation lawyers who try cases throughout Illinois. Peter is a graduate of the University of Chicago Law School, where he has taught trial practice for decades, and he has been recognized as an Illinois Super Lawyer. He has served as lead counsel in more than one hundred class actions and has handled more than one hundred shareholder, LLC, derivative, breach of fiduciary duty, and fraud matters, on both the plaintiff and the defense side. Crain’s Chicago Business credited him with the largest class action settlement of the year for a $40 million recovery in Erikson v. Ameritech, and the firm has been named DuPage County Law Firm of the Year. The firm and its lawyers have represented clients such as McDonald’s, Motorola, and Experian, and have litigated against companies including AT&T and General Motors. James DiTommaso, a graduate of Chicago-Kent College of Law with a certificate in business law, has served with the Illinois Appellate Court and has argued a case before the Illinois Supreme Court. He litigates these disputes in the Illinois trial and appellate courts and in the federal courts. When you hire this firm, the lawyers whose names are on the door are the ones who handle your case.
This post is for general information only. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case turns on its own facts, and prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Attorney Advertising.
Chicago Business Litigation Lawyer Blog

