Expelled From Your Illinois Partnership or LLC? What You Are Owed, and What You Are Not

The email comes from the company’s lawyer, not from your partners. It says the other members met, voted under section 9.4 of the operating agreement, and expelled you effective immediately. Your access to the company’s bank accounts and software has been shut off. The email says nothing about what you will be paid.

You helped build this business. You own 25% of it. Now you are told you are out, and the people who threw you out control the money.

The first answer is the one most expelled owners do not expect. Under Illinois law, an expelled LLC member does not automatically get bought out. An expelled partner in a general partnership usually does. The difference can be worth hundreds of thousands of dollars, and it means the next steps depend on what kind of entity you own and what your agreement says. This post is written for the owner who was pushed out by vote or by notice.

Can my partners or co-members actually expel me?

They can if the agreement or the statute allows it and they follow the required steps.

For an LLC, the LLC Act lists the events that cause a member’s dissociation. They include expulsion “pursuant to the operating agreement,” expulsion by the unanimous vote of the other members in narrow circumstances (for example, when it is unlawful to carry on business with the member), and expulsion by a court. 805 ILCS 180/35-45(4)-(6). A court may expel a member who engaged in wrongful conduct that adversely and materially affected the company’s business, who willfully or persistently committed a material breach of the operating agreement or of the member’s fiduciary duties, or whose conduct makes it not reasonably practicable to carry on the business with that member. 805 ILCS 180/35-45(6).

The Uniform Partnership Act has a nearly identical structure for general partnerships, including expulsion under the partnership agreement, expulsion by unanimous vote in limited circumstances, and judicial expulsion on the same three grounds. 805 ILCS 206/601(3)-(5).

Most expulsions happen under the agreement. That means the agreement’s procedure controls: the vote required, the notice required, any cure period, and any stated grounds. In our experience, expulsions are often defective. Notice went out late, the vote was taken at a meeting no one properly called, or the agreement allows expulsion only for cause and the members never identified any. An expulsion that did not follow the agreement can be challenged as a breach of the agreement.

If I am expelled from an LLC, does the company have to buy me out?

Not automatically, since 2017. Before July 1, 2017, the LLC Act generally required a company to purchase a dissociated member’s distributional interest. The 2017 amendments eliminated that requirement. Now, when a member is dissociated, any distributional interest the member owned is owned “solely as a transferee.” 805 ILCS 180/35-55(a)(4).

A transferee keeps the right to receive distributions the company makes on that interest. A transferee loses the right to vote, to manage, and to participate in company decisions. Put plainly, an expelled member can be left holding an economic interest in a company run by the people who expelled him, with no say in whether that company ever makes a distribution.

Your operating agreement may change this. Many agreements include a buyout on expulsion, often with a price formula. Read that formula carefully. Book value, a fixed multiple, or an accountant’s valuation controlled by the majority can produce a number far below what the interest is worth.

If the agreement gives you nothing, the law still does. The LLC Act allows a court to order judicial dissolution on application by a member or a dissociated member where, among other grounds, the company’s economic purpose is likely to be unreasonably frustrated or it is not reasonably practicable to carry on the business in conformity with the operating agreement. 805 ILCS 180/35-1(a)(4). A member may also seek relief for oppressive conduct by those in control. 805 ILCS 180/35-1(a)(5). In either proceeding, the court may order a remedy other than dissolution, “including, but not limited to, a buyout of the applicant’s distributional interest.” 805 ILCS 180/35-1(b). An expulsion that was a pretext to take your interest cheaply can also support a breach of fiduciary duty claim.

If I am expelled from a general partnership, what am I owed?

A buyout, in most cases. When a partner is dissociated and the partnership continues, the partnership must purchase the dissociated partner’s interest. 805 ILCS 206/701(a). The statute sets the buyout price by reference to what the partner would have received if the partnership’s assets had been sold on the date of dissociation, valued at the greater of liquidation value or the value of the entire business sold as a going concern without the dissociated partner. 805 ILCS 206/701(b). Interest runs from the date of dissociation to the date of payment. 805 ILCS 206/701(b).

The statute has deadlines. If no agreement on price is reached within 120 days after a written demand for payment, the partnership must pay the dissociated partner, in cash, the amount it estimates to be the buyout price plus accrued interest, less offsets. 805 ILCS 206/701(e). A dissociated partner who disagrees can sue to determine the price. The action must be filed within 120 days after the partnership tenders payment or an offer to pay, or within one year after the written demand if the partnership tenders nothing. 805 ILCS 206/701(i). Damages for a wrongful dissociation, along with other amounts the departing partner owes the partnership, are offset against the price. 805 ILCS 206/701(c).

Those deadlines are traps for the unwary. An expelled partner who waits for a better offer can lose the right to contest the partnership’s number.

What if the company is a corporation?

Shareholders are not “expelled” in the statutory sense. A corporation removes a shareholder through a buy-sell agreement, a redemption, or a squeeze-out transaction. If the majority is using its control to force you out, section 12.56 of the Business Corporation Act lets you seek a fair-value buyout without a minority discount, damages, and other relief. 805 ILCS 5/12.56(b), (e). Our post on squeeze-outs in closely held businesses covers the corporate side.

What should I do after receiving an expulsion notice?

First, get the governing documents: the operating or partnership agreement and every amendment, the minutes or written consent of the vote, and the notice itself. Compare the procedure the agreement requires with the procedure the others followed.

Second, calendar every deadline in the agreement and the statute. For a partnership, the 120-day periods in section 701 matter. For an LLC, the agreement’s buyout provisions may have their own notice and election deadlines.

Third, do not concede that the expulsion was valid, and do not accept a payment that is labeled as full satisfaction until you know what your interest is worth.

Fourth, preserve the record and demand information. A dissociated LLC member’s information rights narrowed in 2017, but a dissociated member may still demand, in a record, the information he was entitled to as a member for the period when he was a member, if he seeks it in good faith for a proper purpose. 805 ILCS 180/10-15(d). A partner has a right of access to the partnership’s books and records. 805 ILCS 206/403. See our guide to books and records demands.

Frequently asked questions

Can they expel me without cause?

Only if the agreement allows it. Some agreements permit expulsion without cause, often with a buyout. Others require cause, a vote threshold, notice, and a chance to cure. The statute’s unanimous-vote grounds are narrow.

Do I still own anything after an LLC expulsion?

Yes. You keep your distributional interest as a transferee unless the agreement provides for a purchase. You lose your management and voting rights.

What if the buyout formula in the agreement is unfair?

Courts generally enforce the bargain the owners made. They do not enforce a formula the majority manipulated. Who controls the inputs to a valuation, and whether they used that control honestly, can decide the case.

Can I undo the expulsion?

Sometimes. An expulsion that violated the agreement can be set aside or can support damages. The relief depends on the facts and on what you actually want: back in, or fairly paid to leave.

If you have been expelled from a partnership or LLC, or you expect a vote soon, call DiTommaso Lubin, P.C. at 630-333-0333 for a free consultation, or contact us online.

Big-firm firepower, with the partners on your case

Peter S. Lubin and James V. DiTommaso are Chicago business litigation lawyers who try cases throughout Illinois. Peter is a graduate of the University of Chicago Law School, where he has taught trial practice for decades, and he has been recognized as an Illinois Super Lawyer. He has served as lead counsel in more than one hundred class actions and has handled more than one hundred shareholder, LLC, derivative, breach of fiduciary duty, and fraud matters, on both the plaintiff and the defense side. Crain’s Chicago Business credited him with the largest class action settlement of the year for a $40 million recovery in Erikson v. Ameritech, and the firm has been named DuPage County Law Firm of the Year. The firm and its lawyers have represented clients such as McDonald’s, Motorola, and Experian, and have litigated against companies including AT&T and General Motors. James DiTommaso, a graduate of Chicago-Kent College of Law with a certificate in business law, has served with the Illinois Appellate Court and has argued a case before the Illinois Supreme Court. He litigates these disputes in the Illinois trial and appellate courts and in the federal courts. When you hire this firm, the lawyers whose names are on the door are the ones who handle your case.

This post is for general information only. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case turns on its own facts, and prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Attorney Advertising.

Contact Information