Articles Tagged with libel and slander lawyers and attorneys near Oak Brook and Chicago

An Illinois federal district court dismissed claims of defamation per se and defamation per quod brought as part of a lawsuit alleging employment discrimination, holding that the statements in question amounted to non-actionable opinion. Artunduaga v. University of Chicago Medical Center, at al, No. 12 C 8733, mem. op. (N.D. Ill., May 16, 2013). The motion before the court only sought dismissal of the defamation claims and a claim for intentional interference with employment. The court stated that the statements at issue, while not legally defamatory, could still support the plaintiff’s employment discrimination claims. The case identifies the elements necessary to support a defamation claim under Illinois state law.

The plaintiff began a residency at the University of Chicago Medical Center (UCMC) in June 2011, under the supervision of defendant Dr. David Song. She met with Dr. Song and others in November 2011 in order to discuss her “unsatisfactory performance.” Id. at 2. A memorandum summarizing the meeting was sent to multiple hospital employees. The plaintiff was later placed on probation, and she eventually learned that her one-year contract would not be renewed. Dr. Song sent her a letter on April 30, 2012 that reportedly summarized her employment status and gave her an assignment for the remainder of her residency, with copies to two hospital officials. At a grievance hearing regarding the plaintiff on May 16, 2012, Dr. Song read aloud an email from another doctor containing criticisms of the plaintiff. The plaintiff claimed that Dr. Song added his own “critical assessment[s]” of her performance. Id.

Continue reading ›

Contact Information