A client you have represented for fifteen years calls. You formed her company, drafted the operating agreement, and handle her estate plan. Now she tells you her two co-members have cut off her distributions, stopped sending financial statements, and offered to buy her out for a number that looks like a third of what the business is worth. She wants to know what to do, and she wants you to tell her.
You want to help her. You also know that a business divorce means emergency motions, a valuation fight, and possibly a trial, and that you drafted the agreement everyone will be arguing about.
This post is written for Illinois lawyers who receive these calls: estate planners, corporate and transactional lawyers, family lawyers, and general practitioners. It covers the early deadlines that make these cases urgent, the conflicts that often make referral the right call, and how fee sharing works under Rule 1.5(e) of the Illinois Rules of Professional Conduct.
Why do the first weeks of a shareholder or partner dispute matter so much?
Because several of the most important deadlines are short and some arrive before anyone files suit.
In a closely held corporation, once a shareholder files a petition under section 12.56 of the Business Corporation Act, the corporation or the other shareholders have 90 days to elect to buy the petitioner’s shares at fair value. 805 ILCS 5/12.56(f). Fair value is the shareholder’s proportionate interest “without any discount for minority status or, absent extraordinary circumstances, lack of marketability.” 805 ILCS 5/12.56(e). How the petition is framed, and what record supports it, shapes the negotiation that happens in that window.
In a general partnership, a dissociated partner’s buyout runs on 120-day deadlines after a written demand and after the partnership’s tender or offer. 805 ILCS 206/701. A client who misses them can lose the right to contest the partnership’s number.
In an LLC, the 2017 amendments to the LLC Act changed the economics of departure. A dissociated member now holds his distributional interest “solely as a transferee,” with no automatic buyout. 805 ILCS 180/35-55(a)(4). Clients who assume they will be bought out if they quit or are expelled can make an expensive mistake by walking away first.
Buy-sell provisions bring their own deadlines, and those can be the shortest of all. Illinois courts enforce them, but they also hold majority owners accountable when they manipulate them. In Kazemi v. Maron Electric Co., 2026 IL App (1st) 250908-U, a Rule 23 order, the Appellate Court affirmed a breach of fiduciary duty judgment and punitive damages against a majority owner and CEO who set out to rig the company’s valuation, which reduced a minority shareholder’s contractual buyout to zero.
The outer limitations period is longer. Thompson v. Whalen, 2023 IL App (4th) 220668, holds that the five-year period of 735 ILCS 5/13-205 applies to section 12.56 claims, with the discovery rule. Waiting rarely helps the client, though. Records disappear, cash moves, and the majority’s version of events hardens.
Why is the company’s longtime lawyer often the wrong lawyer for the fight?
Three reasons come up again and again.
First, the entity is usually the client. A lawyer who formed the company or represents it in ordinary matters represents the organization, Ill. R. Prof. Conduct 1.13, and taking one owner’s side against the others can create a conflict under Rule 1.7.
Second, the drafting lawyer is often a witness. When the dispute turns on what an operating agreement or buy-sell clause means, the lawyer who negotiated it may be asked to testify about the drafting history. Rule 3.7 limits a lawyer’s ability to act as advocate at a trial in which the lawyer is likely to be a necessary witness.
Third, the work is litigation. These cases involve temporary restraining orders, books and records demands, forensic accounting, expert valuation testimony, and sometimes a bench trial on fair value. A transactional practice is not built for that pace.
Referring the dispute does not end your relationship with the client. In our experience, the referring lawyer’s role often continues: advising on the estate plan as the ownership changes, helping structure the tax side of a buyout, and returning to ordinary corporate work once the dispute is resolved. We send the client back.
How does referral fee sharing work under Illinois Rule 1.5(e)?
Illinois permits lawyers in different firms to divide a fee if three conditions are met. Ill. R. Prof. Conduct 1.5(e). First, the division must be in proportion to the services each lawyer performs, or, if the primary service one lawyer performs is the referral, each lawyer must assume joint financial responsibility for the representation. Second, the client must agree to the arrangement, including the share each lawyer will receive, and the agreement must be confirmed in writing. Third, the total fee must be reasonable.
The comments to the rule explain that joint financial responsibility means financial responsibility for the representation as if the lawyers were associated in a general partnership. In Ferris, Thompson & Zweig, Ltd. v. Esposito, 2017 IL 121297, the Illinois Supreme Court held that the client’s written agreement need not expressly state that the lawyers have assumed joint financial responsibility; the rule’s conditions are separate, and the writing must confirm the client’s agreement to the arrangement and to each lawyer’s share. Illinois courts have refused to enforce referral agreements that do not satisfy the rule, so the details matter.
The practical steps are simple. Put the referral agreement in writing at the start. Have the client sign it. State each firm’s percentage. If the referring lawyer will do substantive work, describe it. If the referral is the primary service, understand that joint financial responsibility comes with it, and confirm that your malpractice coverage reflects the arrangement.
We honor referral agreements, and we put them in writing at intake.
What should a referring lawyer send us?
The governing documents: articles or certificate of formation, bylaws or operating agreement, any shareholder or buy-sell agreement, and every amendment. The last three years of tax returns and financial statements, if the client has them. Any correspondence about distributions, compensation, removal, or a buyout offer. And a short note on what the client wants: to stay and fix the company, to be bought out at a fair price, or to dissolve.
With that file, we can usually give the client a first assessment quickly, including which deadlines are running and what relief to seek first.
Frequently asked questions
Can I share a fee with the client’s accountant who referred the case to me?
No. Rule 1.5(e) governs fee divisions between lawyers. Rule 5.4 generally bars sharing legal fees with nonlawyers.
Will I stay informed about the case?
Yes, with the client’s consent. We keep referring lawyers updated at the points that matter, and we coordinate with them on estate, tax, and corporate issues the dispute affects.
What if I represent the company and the majority?
Then the minority owner needs separate counsel, and you should think carefully about your own position before giving any owner advice. The same is true in reverse. We represent minority and majority owners, and we check conflicts before every engagement.
Do you co-counsel instead of taking the whole case?
We do, when it fits the client. Some referring lawyers want to stay involved in the litigation. A clear written division of responsibility and fees protects everyone, the client most of all.
If you have a client in a shareholder, LLC member, or partner dispute, call Peter Lubin or James DiTommaso at 630-333-0333 to discuss the matter or a referral, or contact us online. We protect the relationship you have built with your client.
Big-firm firepower, with the partners on your case
Peter S. Lubin and James V. DiTommaso are Chicago business litigation lawyers who try cases throughout Illinois. Peter is a graduate of the University of Chicago Law School, where he has taught trial practice for decades, and he has been recognized as an Illinois Super Lawyer. He has served as lead counsel in more than one hundred class actions and has handled more than one hundred shareholder, LLC, derivative, breach of fiduciary duty, and fraud matters, on both the plaintiff and the defense side. Crain’s Chicago Business credited him with the largest class action settlement of the year for a $40 million recovery in Erikson v. Ameritech, and the firm has been named DuPage County Law Firm of the Year. The firm and its lawyers have represented clients such as McDonald’s, Motorola, and Experian, and have litigated against companies including AT&T and General Motors. James DiTommaso, a graduate of Chicago-Kent College of Law with a certificate in business law, has served with the Illinois Appellate Court and has argued a case before the Illinois Supreme Court. He litigates these disputes in the Illinois trial and appellate courts and in the federal courts. When you hire this firm, the lawyers whose names are on the door are the ones who handle your case.
This post is for general information only. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case turns on its own facts, and prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Attorney Advertising.
Chicago Business Litigation Lawyer Blog

