A longtime customer mentions, almost in passing, that she enjoyed working with your partner’s “new outfit.” You have never heard of a new outfit. A week later you find the registration on the Secretary of State’s website: an LLC formed eight months ago, managed by your partner, doing exactly what your company does, from an address ten minutes away.
You start pulling invoices. Three of your best accounts have gone quiet. A bid the company was supposed to submit never went out.
If you own an Illinois company with a partner who is taking its business for himself, Illinois law treats that as a breach of the duty of loyalty, and the remedies can reach every dollar he made. This post is written for the owner on the losing end, and it explains the corporate opportunity doctrine, the proof that wins these cases, and the first moves to make.
What is the corporate opportunity doctrine in Illinois?
It is the rule that a fiduciary may not take for himself a business opportunity that belongs to the company. The Illinois Supreme Court set the standard in Kerrigan v. Unity Savings Ass’n, 58 Ill. 2d 20 (1974). Directors of a savings and loan formed their own insurance agency and sold insurance to the association’s borrowers. The court held that they breached their duty because they never disclosed the opportunity to the association and gave it the chance to take the business itself.
The rule that comes out of Kerrigan is strict. A fiduciary who learns of an opportunity in the company’s line of business must disclose it and tender it to the company first. He cannot decide on his own that the company could not have used it or would not have wanted it. That decision belongs to the company, made with full information.
The LLC Act and the Uniform Partnership Act write the same duty into statute. In a member-managed LLC, a member’s duty of loyalty includes the duty to account for and hold as trustee “any property, profit, or benefit” derived from the company’s business or property, “including the appropriation of a company’s opportunity.” 805 ILCS 180/15-3(b)(1). In a manager-managed LLC, the managers are held to the same standards. 805 ILCS 180/15-3(g). A partner owes the same duty as to “a partnership opportunity.” 805 ILCS 206/404(b)(1). Both statutes also bar competing with the business before dissolution.
Does my partner owe that duty if he is not an officer?
Usually yes. In Hagshenas v. Gaylord, 199 Ill. App. 3d 60 (1990), the defendant owned half of a travel agency. He had resigned as an officer and director, and he argued that as a 50% shareholder he owed no fiduciary duty. The appellate court disagreed. Shareholders in a closely held corporation who act like partners owe each other duties like partners, and the court held he breached his duty when he set up a competing agency, hired away the agency’s employees, and solicited its customers.
The same logic reaches most small companies. If your partner had access to the customers, the bids, the pricing, and the books, he was in a position of trust, and Illinois treats him accordingly. We discuss the duties owners owe each other in more depth in What Your Business Partner Owes You Under Illinois Law.
What counts as the company’s opportunity?
The core test is whether the opportunity falls within the company’s line of business or is reasonably related to it. A contract with an existing customer, a bid the company was preparing, a supplier relationship, a piece of real estate next to the company’s plant, a new product line the company was developing: each of these can belong to the company.
Defendants usually raise three arguments. The company could not afford it. The customer would not have dealt with the company. The opportunity came to him personally. Kerrigan answers much of this, because the remedy for a fiduciary who thinks the company cannot use an opportunity is to disclose it and let the company decide. A fiduciary who skipped that step bears the risk of the choice he made alone.
In our experience, these cases are won on documents. The formation papers for the new entity, the date of the first invoice it sent to one of your customers, the emails he sent from the company account to his personal account, the bid files, the phone records. A timeline that shows the new company was formed while he was still collecting a salary from yours is often the most persuasive exhibit in the case.
What can a court order him to pay?
More than lost profits. In Graham v. Mimms, 111 Ill. App. 3d 751 (1982), a controlling shareholder diverted condominium conversion projects from the company to entities he controlled. The appellate court affirmed the finding that he misappropriated those opportunities because he never disclosed and tendered them, and it affirmed restitution of almost $1.4 million against him and the relatives who helped him. The court explained that restitution for a usurped opportunity can be compelled through a constructive trust, which treats the profits as the company’s property held in trust by the wrongdoer. It reversed the trial court’s decision to put a constructive trust on all property of his new company, so the remedy must track what the diverted opportunities produced.
The available relief can include an accounting of everything the new business earned, disgorgement of profits, damages for the company’s lost business, forfeiture of compensation paid during the period of disloyalty, and an injunction against further diversion. Where the conduct is willful, Illinois courts have affirmed punitive damages against disloyal co-owners. See ICD Publications, Inc. v. Gittlitz, 2014 IL App (1st) 133277 (affirming complete forfeiture of a one-third owner’s compensation and $2 million in punitive damages after he concealed and diverted company funds), and Kovac v. Barron, 2014 IL App (2d) 121100 (holding that a 50% owner could recover punitive damages for his co-owner’s breach of fiduciary duty, even after the co-owner died while the case was pending).
Is the claim mine or the company’s?
Often the company’s. When the harm is a lost opportunity or diverted profits, the injury usually runs to the company, and the claim may need to be brought derivatively on the company’s behalf. Derivative suits have their own procedural rules, including demand requirements. Our post on Illinois derivative lawsuits walks through them. In a closely held corporation, a shareholder may also seek relief under section 12.56 of the Business Corporation Act, which lists misapplication or waste of corporate assets as a ground for relief. 805 ILCS 5/12.56(a)(4).
Can the operating agreement let him compete?
Sometimes. Since 2022 the LLC Act has allowed an operating agreement to restrict or even eliminate fiduciary duties, but only if the agreement does so in clear and unambiguous terms. 805 ILCS 180/15-5(c)(1). An agreement may also identify specific types or categories of activities that do not violate the duty of loyalty. 805 ILCS 180/15-5(c)(4). Some agreements expressly permit members to run other businesses. Vague language does not waive anything, and an agreement that permits a member to own a separate real estate venture does not permit him to divert your customers. The exact words matter, so the operating agreement is the first document we read.
What should I do now?
Move quickly. Every week the new company operates, it locks in more of your customers.
Preserve the evidence you lawfully hold, and do not log into accounts you have no right to access. Demand the company’s books and records under 805 ILCS 5/7.75 or 805 ILCS 180/10-15. Map which customers, bids, and employees moved, and when. Then talk with a lawyer about emergency relief. A temporary restraining order under 735 ILCS 5/11-101 can stop further diversion while the case proceeds, and our post on emergency relief when a partner is draining the accounts explains how Illinois judges approach these requests.
Frequently asked questions
Can my partner take customers after he leaves the company?
It depends on the timing, any restrictive covenant, and how he got them. Preparing to compete while still an owner is treated differently from competing after a clean departure. Soliciting customers while still a fiduciary, or using the company’s confidential information to do it, can be a breach even if he resigns first.
What if he says the customer came to him personally?
That is a common defense. The question is whether the business was in the company’s line and whether he learned of it through his role. Kerrigan puts the burden of disclosure on the fiduciary.
Can I get an injunction quickly?
Illinois courts can enter a temporary restraining order on short notice when a party shows a clear right, irreparable harm, and the lack of an adequate remedy at law. The request is stronger when it is narrow and backed by documents.
If you believe a partner is diverting your company’s business, call DiTommaso Lubin, P.C. at 630-333-0333 for a free consultation, or contact us online.
Big-firm firepower, with the partners on your case
Peter S. Lubin and James V. DiTommaso are Chicago business litigation lawyers who try cases throughout Illinois. Peter is a graduate of the University of Chicago Law School, where he has taught trial practice for decades, and he has been recognized as an Illinois Super Lawyer. He has served as lead counsel in more than one hundred class actions and has handled more than one hundred shareholder, LLC, derivative, breach of fiduciary duty, and fraud matters, on both the plaintiff and the defense side. Crain’s Chicago Business credited him with the largest class action settlement of the year for a $40 million recovery in Erikson v. Ameritech, and the firm has been named DuPage County Law Firm of the Year. The firm and its lawyers have represented clients such as McDonald’s, Motorola, and Experian, and have litigated against companies including AT&T and General Motors. James DiTommaso, a graduate of Chicago-Kent College of Law with a certificate in business law, has served with the Illinois Appellate Court and has argued a case before the Illinois Supreme Court. He litigates these disputes in the Illinois trial and appellate courts and in the federal courts. When you hire this firm, the lawyers whose names are on the door are the ones who handle your case.
This post is for general information only. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case turns on its own facts, and prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Attorney Advertising.
Chicago Business Litigation Lawyer Blog

