The envelope from the company’s accountant arrives in March, as it does every year. Inside is a Schedule K-1 reporting $140,000 of income allocated to you. You owe tax on that income. You did not receive a dollar of it.
The company had a good year. The majority owner’s salary went up. His wife joined the payroll. The building the company leases from his real estate entity got a new, higher lease. Distributions to the owners stopped two years ago, and every request for an explanation gets the same answer: the company needs to keep its cash.
Owners of S corporations and LLCs taxed as partnerships pay tax on their share of the company’s income whether or not the company distributes it. When the people in control keep the cash, pay themselves through other channels, and leave the minority holding the tax bill, Illinois law can treat that as oppression. This post is for the minority owner receiving K-1s without checks, and it explains the claims and remedies Illinois provides.
What is phantom income, and why is it a freeze-out tool?
Pass-through entities do not pay federal income tax at the entity level. The income flows through to the owners, who report their shares on their personal returns. If the company keeps the cash, each owner still owes tax on the allocated income. Owners call that “phantom income.” Your accountant can explain how it applies to your own return.
For the majority, phantom income is leverage. Year after year, the minority owner writes checks to the IRS and the State of Illinois for income he never sees. Meanwhile, the majority owner draws a salary, a bonus, and rent, so the company’s profits reach him through other doors. Sooner or later, the minority owner is tired and out of pocket, and a low offer for his interest starts to look like relief. That is the point.
Is it oppression to stop paying distributions?
Not always. Companies have real reasons to retain cash: debt covenants, expansion, a bad year ahead. Courts give business judgment room. The question is whether the decision to retain cash serves the company or serves a plan to squeeze out the minority.
For an Illinois corporation, section 12.56 of the Business Corporation Act lets a shareholder seek relief if those in control “have acted, are acting, or will act in a manner that is illegal, oppressive, or fraudulent with respect to the petitioning shareholder.” 805 ILCS 5/12.56(a)(3). Oppression does not require fraud or illegality. Central Standard Life Insurance Co. v. Davis, 10 Ill. 2d 566 (1957); Gidwitz v. Lanzit Corrugated Box Co., 20 Ill. 2d 208 (1960). The appellate court has described oppressive conduct as “arbitrary, overbearing and heavy-handed.” Compton v. Paul K. Harding Realty Co., 6 Ill. App. 3d 488 (1972). In Compton, the court also ordered the company’s president to repay salary he took in excess of what the owners had agreed he would be paid.
For an LLC, the parallel remedy applies when those in control “have acted or are acting in a manner that is oppressive and was, is, or will be directly harmful to the applicant.” 805 ILCS 180/35-1(a)(5)(B).
In our experience, the strongest phantom income cases share a pattern. Distributions stop at the same time the minority owner is fired, removed from management, or begins asking questions. Profits keep coming, and they flow to the majority as compensation, management fees, related-party rent, or personal expenses run through the company. The majority offers no written explanation of why the cash is needed. When those facts line up, the “we need to retain earnings” defense sounds less like business judgment and more like a squeeze.
What if the majority is paying itself instead?
Then the case often turns into a fiduciary duty case as well. Controlling owners of a closely held company owe fiduciary duties to the company and, in many circumstances, to the other owners. Paying yourself an excessive salary, steering rent to your own building, or putting family members on the payroll can breach those duties when the payments exceed fair value for what the company receives. We address the compensation issue in detail in Can Taking Excessive Compensation Violate a Managing Member or Majority Shareholder’s Fiduciary Duties?
What can a court order?
For a corporation, section 12.56(b) gives the court a broad menu. The court can order an accounting, order the payment of dividends, award damages, set aside improper transactions, remove an officer or director, appoint a custodian, or order the corporation or the other shareholders to buy the petitioner’s shares at fair value. 805 ILCS 5/12.56(b). Fair value means the shareholder’s proportionate interest “without any discount for minority status or, absent extraordinary circumstances, lack of marketability.” 805 ILCS 5/12.56(e).
For an LLC, the court may order a remedy other than dissolution, “including, but not limited to, a buyout of the applicant’s distributional interest.” 805 ILCS 180/35-1(b).
The buyout is often the practical answer. A minority owner who has been paying tax on phantom income for years usually wants out. The statute lets the court require the majority to pay fair value, and in a corporation a court can also order a fee award against a party that acted arbitrarily, vexatiously, or otherwise not in good faith. 805 ILCS 5/12.60(j).
Does my operating agreement or shareholder agreement help?
Look for a tax distribution clause. Many well-drafted operating agreements and S corporation shareholder agreements require the company to distribute enough cash each year for the owners to pay the tax on their allocated income. If yours has one and the company ignored it, you may have a straightforward breach of contract claim in addition to any oppression claim.
Also look at how the agreement handles distributions generally. Some give the manager full discretion. Others require distributions of available cash. Discretion is still limited: the LLC Act applies the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing to every operating agreement. 805 ILCS 180/15-3(d).
What should I do now?
Start with information. Demand the company’s books and records, including tax returns, general ledgers, payroll records, related-party agreements, and bank statements. Shareholders have a statutory inspection right under 805 ILCS 5/7.75, and LLC members under 805 ILCS 180/10-15. See our guide to forcing a company to open its books.
Then assemble the numbers: income allocated to you by year, distributions received by year, taxes you paid on the difference, and what the majority received in salary, bonus, rent, and benefits over the same years. That chart is often the first exhibit in the case.
Do not sign a release or sell your interest to make the tax bills stop until you know what the interest is worth. Our post on fair value buyouts explains why the first offer is rarely the right number.
Frequently asked questions
Can I recover the taxes I paid on income I never received?
Your damages depend on your claims and on the company’s agreements. A tax distribution clause gives the clearest path. Without one, the tax burden can still be part of the oppression story and can bear on the remedy a court fashions.
Can the majority simply say the company needs the cash?
It can say so. A court will ask whether the record supports it. Growing reserves while the majority’s own compensation rises is hard to explain as a need for cash.
Does any of this change if the company is an LLC?
The statute changes, and the operating agreement carries more weight. The core ideas are the same: those in control cannot use their control to strip the minority of the economic value of its ownership. Our post on LLC member freeze-outs covers the LLC remedies.
If you are paying tax on income your company will not distribute, call DiTommaso Lubin, P.C. at 630-333-0333 for a free consultation, or contact us online.
Big-firm firepower, with the partners on your case
Peter S. Lubin and James V. DiTommaso are Chicago business litigation lawyers who try cases throughout Illinois. Peter is a graduate of the University of Chicago Law School, where he has taught trial practice for decades, and he has been recognized as an Illinois Super Lawyer. He has served as lead counsel in more than one hundred class actions and has handled more than one hundred shareholder, LLC, derivative, breach of fiduciary duty, and fraud matters, on both the plaintiff and the defense side. Crain’s Chicago Business credited him with the largest class action settlement of the year for a $40 million recovery in Erikson v. Ameritech, and the firm has been named DuPage County Law Firm of the Year. The firm and its lawyers have represented clients such as McDonald’s, Motorola, and Experian, and have litigated against companies including AT&T and General Motors. James DiTommaso, a graduate of Chicago-Kent College of Law with a certificate in business law, has served with the Illinois Appellate Court and has argued a case before the Illinois Supreme Court. He litigates these disputes in the Illinois trial and appellate courts and in the federal courts. When you hire this firm, the lawyers whose names are on the door are the ones who handle your case.
This post is for general information only. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case turns on its own facts, and prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Attorney Advertising.
Chicago Business Litigation Lawyer Blog

